Turtle Pumpkin Pie

I am really surprised at the bad reviews. The pie came out perfect and sliced very well. It was a huge hit at Thanksgiving and I will make it again. I did change a few things. I used crushed salted peanuts, which worked really well with the caramel and crust. I also used sugar free, fat free cheesecake pudding. I think the SF, FF pudding may have less content then regular pudding. I also made the pie the day of the party so the crust wouldn't have time to get soggy. I definitely suggest making it!

This tastes like it was alot of trouble to make but is not. Tastes like it has liqueur in it and is very rich. Makes a beautiful presentation, too.

I made the turtle pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving. My family loved it. The recipe wasn't too much more difficult than just a regular pumpkin pie.

I made this for thanksgiving, for a new twist, than just grandma's pumpkin pie, everyone loved it, even gram. i also made this for my daughters parent celebration and everyone loved it there also, they always want me to bring it, now!

Filling was too soft. Did not cut into slices like the picture. Next time maybe not as much pumpkin.

Fabulous! The pumpkin was light and creamy; the "turtle" was rich! EVERYONE loved it- even people who don't like pumpkin pie. I will DEFINITELY make it again- and was VERY quick to make!

This was delicious! It was a huge hit!

Very simple and easy to make. My 5 year old and I made it. Very sweet though. Some family members loved it, others said it was too sweet. I agreed with both. I likely would not make this again because it wasn't my style. Someone else might lov it though. Don't pass it over. Definately try it.

AWESOME Make sure you try this pie for your self & family

This is Amazing!! We had it at Thanksgiving with my husbands family and I will be making it for my family this weekend!! Yummy11