I rated it a 5 because it SOUNDS so good! I am going to make this recipe but will use the pineapple liquid instead of any water and probably some pineapple flavoring, low carb milk if it calls for milk, sugar free pudding and sugar free Whiped topping or make my own. I would forego the fruit. I haven't figured all that up yet and no it isn't lowcarb but it would be lower sugar, lower fat and lower carb than the original and I would have to try not to eat the all the cupcakes myself. :)