I made this for my family, and it was pretty good. My picky 3 year old ate it, so that was a plus. The potatoes were really good, and I agree with all the other reviews, definitely cook them in the microwave longer prior to baking. I cooked them 12 minutes, and I still don't think that was long enough. My husband said that there was too much rosemary, so I think next time I'll alter the recipe a bit and add something other than rosemary. It was worth trying it out, though!