The taste was very good and I liked the density of the icing--had a nice, thicker texture. However, my cake did break apart in two places when trying to roll with the icing, it actually stuck to my towel in places, too, which made it cumbersome to complete as well. Because the icing was so dense, I WAS able to get it rolled up even with the two breaks--the icing helped keep it together, and once I rolled it and wrapped tightly in saran (I made mine without icing like a pumpkin roll) and refrigerated it, it didn't held together ok, but doubt I would make again because of the problems.