Yuck. I made the chicken variation and like a previous reviewer said, it did not hold together very well. My husband had to make a sandwich because he couldn't eat it. I used ground chicken, so that probably had a lot to with the texture problems, but the combination of chicken, potatoes, bbq sauce, and cheese was disgusting. The potatoes came out soggy even though I baked it for longer than the recipe said. If I try this again, I'll try the beef variation.