Made this for Memorial Day which was also husband's bday, and everyone loved it. It looked just like the picture. I also added two very ripe thinly sliced bananas over the chocolate before the ice cream. Husband doesn't care for chocolate ice cream, so I used a S'more ice cream, and it was delish! I made the crust and chocolate the night before and finished it the next morning to eliminate some of the wait times too. Broiled right before serving, so the top was warm and had that great toasted marshmallow aroma! Yummy!